From Fiction to Cult: The Legacy and Reclamation of H.P. Lovecraft

Introduction: A Strange and Tentacled Legacy

There’s something eerie about reading Lovecraft late at night—not just because of the monsters, but because part of your mind whispers: What if some of this is real?

What started as fictional horror tales by a xenophobic recluse from Rhode Island has grown into a mythos with real-world rituals, fan devotion, magical experimentation, literary reclamation, and cultural critique.

This is the strange afterlife of H.P. Lovecraft—a man whose fears became monsters, whose monsters became myths, and whose myths are now being reclaimed by the very people he feared.

This is a story about horror, belief, transformation, and why it matters who gets to write the myth.

Part I: How Lovecraft’s Fiction Became a Cult Phenomenon

H.P. Lovecraft (1890–1937) was a horror writer who gave birth to a new kind of fear: cosmic horror—the dread that the universe is vast, uncaring, and incomprehensibly alien. His most iconic creation, Cthulhu, was never meant to be worshipped. He was meant to symbolize madness itself.

But here we are, a century later, and people are:

• Buying Necronomicon spellbooks

• Playing Cthulhu-themed tarot

• Performing rituals to fictional gods

• Writing academic papers and fan fiction in equal measure
  

How did this happen?

A Mythos Born in Pulp

Lovecraft wrote short stories for Weird Tales, developing a network of interlinked tales, fake books (The Necronomicon), unpronounceable gods (Nyarlathotep, Yog-Sothoth), and fictional places (Arkham, Innsmouth). He even encouraged other writers to borrow and expand his world—creating a shared mythos before cinematic universes existed.

After his death, authors like August Derleth kept the mythos alive, though Derleth added a Christian-like good vs. evil framework that Lovecraft never intended.

Occultists Take Notice

By the 1970s, chaos magicians and occultists started treating Lovecraft’s creations as egregores—archetypal thoughtforms that can gain power through belief and repetition.

Notable examples include:

• Kenneth Grant, who claimed Lovecraft was an unknowing channel of real occult truth

• The Simon Necronomicon (1977), a published grimoire claiming to reveal rituals to the Old Ones

• Magical systems that blend Mythos beings with real-world ritual to provoke altered states
  

Some use these rituals seriously. Others ironically. But the line between satire and spiritual experience is thin and porous—and that’s part of the magic.

Part II: The Horror of Empire – Lovecraft’s Racism and What It Reveals

We can’t talk about Lovecraft without talking about his intense racism, xenophobia, and fear of miscegenation. He wasn’t just writing monsters—he was writing his own social panic.

His stories often feature:

• "Degenerate races" worshipping ancient gods

• Horrors born from “mixing bloodlines”

• Ancient non-Western civilizations with “forbidden knowledge”
  

It’s disturbing. And it’s real.

So Why Read Him at All?

Because Lovecraft’s fears mirror the subconscious of empire. His work gives us a map of how colonial panic, white supremacy, and fear of the Other can crystallize into stories that infect culture.

Studying his work helps us:

• Understand how myth absorbs racism

• Name the fears that shaped modern horror

• Build stories that heal rather than replicate harm
  

Part III: Reclaiming the Mythos – Writers of Color Speak Back

In recent years, Lovecraft’s mythos has become a site of literary resistance and reclamation. Writers of color are not just critiquing Lovecraft—they are using his monsters to tell the truth.

Victor LaValle – The Ballad of Black Tom

LaValle retells Lovecraft’s The Horror at Red Hook—a deeply racist story—from the perspective of a Black man. His novella doesn’t rewrite the mythos to be more palatable—it exposes the horror of racism as the true monster.

“The monster wasn’t Cthulhu. It was the world he lived in.”

Matt Ruff – Lovecraft Country

Both the novel and the HBO adaptation reframe Lovecraftian horror through the lens of the Black experience in Jim Crow America. Magic becomes a tool of survival and resistance—not just madness.

The message? You want cosmic horror? Try living while Black in 1950s America.

Silvia Moreno-Garcia – Mexican Gothic

While not directly referencing Lovecraft, Moreno-Garcia plays with cosmic dread, eugenics, and colonialism in a Gothic Mexican setting—reclaiming horror tropes and giving them new cultural teeth.

Part IV: Myth is Mutable – and That’s the Power

Lovecraft’s monsters may have started as symbols of supremacist fear, but that doesn’t mean they have to stay that way.

Myths aren’t static. They evolve, fracture, and are rewritten.

Modern writers, artists, witches, and weirdos are:

• De-centering whiteness in horror

• Queering the Mythos

• Turning the madness inward—to interrogate systemic violence

• Using eldritch horror to explore climate grief, neurodivergence, colonial trauma, and identity
  

When we know how myth works, we can stop letting it haunt us—and start using it to heal.

Final Reflections: Tentacles and Truth

Maybe Lovecraft was right. Maybe the truth is vast, unknowable, and indifferent to human plans.

But what he didn’t see coming was this: That people from the margins—those he feared and reviled—would be the ones to pick up his mythos and say:

“Actually? We’re not afraid of you.We are the dark. And we have stories of our own.”

Want More Mythic Makeovers and Literary Exorcisms? Subscribe to the Weird Sisters Wellness newsletter for more witchy book history, spiritual reclamation, and storytelling from the margins.